10 years on Image

10 years on

Finally the fog lifts on South Wharf

Away from the desk Image

Away from the desk

The little bent tree

Chamber update Image

Chamber update

Another great year

Docklander Image


Hats off to you, Premier, but remember, we’ll all be watching …

Docklands Secrets Image

Docklands Secrets

Conflicting speeds

Fashion Image


Top five street style trends

Business Image


Golden Fleece enters a golden age

Owners Corporation Law Image

Owners Corporation Law

New Owners’ Corporation Bill reads like a “favour for mates”

Pets Corner Image

Pets Corner

Odd couple enjoy waterside company

Precinct Perspectives

Yarra’s Edge - Precinct Perspective

SkyPad Living Image

SkyPad Living

The vertical commons

Street Art Image

Street Art

Goodbye from Blender Studios


Eat sustainably!

The District

ArtVo returns with brand new art

We Live Here Image

We Live Here

Proposed changes to the Owners’ Corporation Act

Abby's Angle  Image

Abby's Angle

The Silly Season

Extended free tram zone: Good move or bad?

29 Oct 2019

Extended free tram zone: Good move or bad? Image

By David Schout

As state parliament considers the merit of extending the free tram zone, it appears people are split on whether free rides should extend beyond the CBD and Docklands.

In June, Transport Matters MP Rod Barton passed an upper house motion to consider extending the zone.

His suggestion included an expansion to major destinations such as the MCG, Art Centre and Melbourne Zoo, plus key institutions like the Alfred and Royal Children’s Hospitals, and the University of Melbourne.

Public submissions are open until December 20.

While the state government has shown no indication yet of extending the zone, the question of how it would impact commuters remains a pertinent one.

And one thing is certain: people are divided on the zone’s effectiveness.

Introduced at the start of 2015, supporters of the scheme spruik its cost and convenience benefits.

Mr Barton said extending the zone to include areas outside the CBD would be another step towards changing the way people choose to get around.

“We want to encourage visitors to these areas,” he said.

“We want to encourage locals into these areas. It makes sense to encourage tram travel to these major destinations and encourage everyone to enjoy all that Melbourne has to offer.”

An extension to the free tram zone would appear, from the outside, as a win for locals. It would extend the areas they can travel for free to include key city venues and services.

Docklands News recently asked several passers-by whether they would like to see the free tram zone extended to the arts and sports precincts. Each respondent said they would.

But others, especially those who live outside the CBD, have suggested it would further clog a system that is becoming unusable at peak hour.

Those who commute to and from the city by train each day don’t benefit from the “free” trams: their Myki caps at $8.80 irrespective of whether they take trams or not.

As a result, the main beneficiaries of the free tram zone would appear to be local residents, tourists or those who travel into the city by car.

In a surprise revelation, the state government’s recently released annual tram load survey claimed that, contrary to accounts of overcrowding, packed trams were in fact a rarity within the CBD.

It found just four instances of CBD trams past capacity during a nine-day period in May.

This compared to 11 instances in the same survey last year.

All four “load breaches” occurred during the morning peak of 8am-9.30am, meaning there were no recorded instances of overcrowding in the evening peak.

But the Public Transport Users Association (PTUA) questioned the survey’s measurement, specifically the locations used to count passengers which were each located at the end of the free tram zone.

“The official numbers reckon Yarra Trams services mostly aren’t overcrowded. That’s because they’re measuring them on the edge of the CBD - away from where the trams are most packed,” the PTUA tweeted.

Despite the obvious benefits to locals and tourists, City of Melbourne councillors have expressed caution on a free tram zone extension.

Cr Rohan Leppert has said on Twitter that extending the zone would be a bad idea.

“Our public transport system is under intense pressure in the CBD,” he wrote.


Share on Facebook

Stay in touch with Docklands. Subscribe to FREE monthly e-Newspaper.

You must be registered with Docklands News to be able to post comments.
To register, please click here.