10 years on Image

10 years on

World change starts at Docklands

Away from the desk Image

Away from the desk

The little bent tree

Chamber update Image

Chamber update

Visit Docklands – our brand-new website

Docklander Image


Your new life starts now

Docklands Secrets Image

Docklands Secrets

Politician disrespects us

Fashion Image


Top five street style trends

Health and Wellbeing Image

Health and Wellbeing

Lifestyle focus – Importance of sleep

Letters Image


Letters to the Editor

New Businesses Image

New Businesses

NeoLemonade and Melbourne Cellar Door

Owners Corporation Law Image

Owners Corporation Law

OCs will be forced to fix the dodgy cladding

Pets Corner Image

Pets Corner

Cyberbuns in Docklands

Street Art Image

Street Art

Docklands is becoming cool

We Live Here Image

We Live Here

Government ignores Airbnb stabbing death

What Women Want - With Abby Crawford Image

What Women Want - With Abby Crawford

Some things just sure are meant to be

Local democracy is fading away

04 Oct 2017

Local democracy is fading away Image

By Shane Scanlan

City of Melbourne councillors are making only about a third of the number of public decisions they were making 10 years ago.

Between January and July this year, CBD News counted from minutes 131 decisions made in council and committee meetings. During the corresponding period in 2007, the number was 365.

Even Victoria’s smallest municipality, the Borough of Queenscliffe, records more publicly-made decisions than Melbourne. Queenscliffe’s councillors made 148 decisions between January and July this year.

As a ratio of decisions to population, Queenscliffe locals are 100 times better represented than their Melbourne compatriots. And this ratio doubles if you consider decisions per councillor numbers.

Queensliffe may not be an entirely fair comparator but the point is that the City of Melbourne has moved steadily over the decades to a corporate model where decisions are most likely to be either taken in secret or delegated to unelected officers.

As of last month, some 760 applications for planning permits had been lodged with the City of Melbourne. Only a selected handful came to an open meetings for determination. The opportunity for corruption has never been better.

A culture exists at the City of Melbourne where elected representatives are increasingly sidelined. Anything remotely contentious is held in confidential session. And councillors face criminal charges if they reveal what’s said behind closed doors.

The council also routinely stymies freedom of information (FoI) requests and spends about $1 million per year on spin doctors.

Lord Mayor Robert Doyle rejects any suggestion that participatory democracy is on the slide within the City of Melbourne.

Asked about shrinking agendas, he said: “The community satisfaction survey shows us at record highs in community engagement – far beyond any other council in Victoria. So I think that’s a pretty specious claim. And, secondly, our agendas are, regrettably, pretty lumpy. You know, sometimes they are thin and sometimes, to our distress, they are pretty fat. And that’s just the nature of timing as things come through.”

“When you make that comment, there’s a little naivety of comparison in that. Most councils meet once a month. Your council meets three times a month – with agendas that are pretty full most of the time. I think in terms of meeting content, it would be difficult to find any other council in Victoria which deals with as many items as we do.”

The Borough of Queenscliffe Council meets once a month, but between January and July averaged 21.14 decisions per meeting. The City of Melbourne’s average is 6.89 decisions from 19 meetings.

Looking back to the same period in 2007, the City of Melbourne met 37 times and averaged 9.86 decisions per meeting. Councillors are meeting less and are making fewer decisions.

Share on Facebook

Stay in touch with Docklands. Subscribe to FREE monthly e-Newspaper.

You must be registered with Docklands News to be able to post comments.
To register, please click here.

Docklands is Beautiful